Dans cet arrêt de grande chambre rendu à l’unanimité, la Cour européenne des droits de l’homme condamne la formulation de propos négationnistes, même dans l’arène politique, en identifiant un abus du droit à la liberté d’expression.
Le chroniqueur judiciaire Julien Mucchielli, collaborateur au sein de Dalloz actualité, reprend le dossier de François Darcy, condamné pour avoir assassiné son épouse le 26 avril 2012. Dans un livre-enquête passionnant, l’auteur pointe les défauts des investigations menées dans cette affaire, tout en relatant les deux procès d’assises.
In C-215/18 Libuše Králová v Primera Air Scandinavia, Saugmandsgaard ØE AG now unsurprisingly (following the CJEU predecent of Feniks and Flightright), advised that in a package of services acquired from a travel agent, where there is no direct agreement with the airline carrying out the flight part of the package, there is a ‘contract’ between the individual and the airline within the meaning of Article 7(1) BIa.
At 37 the AG emphasises the element of predictability on the part of the airline, who should not be surprised to be sued by the individual whom they agree with the travel agency to transport, both in the place of take-off and landing, per Zurich Insurance.
However unlike the Commission, the AG supports a less extensive interpretation of the consumer section. Package travel as defined in Directive 90/314, unlike simple tickets for transport only, are covered by the protective provisions of Article 17 ff BIa. Yet the AG proposes to extend that regime only to the direct relationship between the travel agent and the consumer, not the airline who merely carries out the transport side of the arrangement. At 48 ff the AG sets out his reasons for the limitation: the emphasis in the consumer section on the very consumer and professional party who concluded the contract (48-49); the distinction with Maletic since in the case at issue claimant is after the airline company only, not an in solidum finding against the agency and the airline (5-52); and of course the need for strict interpretation.
Note of course the different balance struck by the AG as opposed to e.g. the High Court in Bonnie Lackey.
Geert.
(Handbook of) European private international law, 2nd ed. 2016, Chapter 2, Heading 2.2.8.2.
L’arrêt rapporté vient enrichir le contentieux des restitutions durant l’instruction en apportant d’intéressantes précisions.
The XXth volume of the Yearbook of Private International Law has just been published. Ilaria Pretelli, who has edited this volume together with Andrea Bonomi and Gian Paolo Romano, has been so kind as to provide not only the following teaser but also the Table of Contents and Foreword to conflictoflaws.net.
The new 20th volume (2018/2019) of the Yearbook of Private International Law contains over 30 articles on the most important aspects of private international law by authors from all over the world. You will find inspiring articles on the law of non-recognised states, the American restatement on international arbitration, the recognition of so-called marriage for all in Europe and, highly topical, a contribution to the Hague Judgments Convention and the reform of the Brussels IIa Regulation.
As always, the National Reports with information on relevant legal developments worldwide, News from the Hague, the case law section and also the forum are highly interesting and unique.
Hospitalisation sans consentement
Sécurité sociale
Sécurité sociale
Sécurité sociale - Cotisations et contributions du régime général
Sécurité sociale- Accident du travail
Sécurité sociale, cotisations et contributions du régime général
Contrat
Saisie
Filiation - Conflit de loi
Theme by Danetsoft and Danang Probo Sayekti inspired by Maksimer